Stay up to date

Online Ordering

The Power Of Restaurant Loyalty Programs In The Digital Age

Picture of ItsaCheckmate
By ItsaCheckmate on February, 16 2024

In an industry where discounts are no longer enough, discover how modern restaurant loyalty programs can give your business a competitive edge.


In today's fiercely competitive restaurant industry, simply dishing out delectable food and top-notch service isn't enough to turn heads. The digital revolution has introduced online ordering, transforming the way consumers interact with eateries. Amid this change, loyalty programs have emerged as an essential tool for restaurants. These programs go beyond traditional rewards or discounts; they're strategic drivers designed to retain customers, boost sales, and strengthen brand value. As a restaurant owner in the digital age, leaning into loyalty programs can be your game-changer, offering you the edge needed to rise above the competition.


What Are Restaurant Loyalty Programs?

Importance Of Loyalty Programs In The Restaurant Industry

Why Your Restaurant Needs A Loyalty Program

What Are The Best Restaurant Loyalty Program Incentives?

Successful Examples Of Restaurant Loyalty Programs


What Are Restaurant Loyalty Programs?

Customer loyalty programs have become a cornerstone for restaurants to ensure regular patronage and customer satisfaction. These are essentially reward systems that offer exclusive benefits or perks to regular customers, incentivizing them for their repeated business. Typically, customers can sign up for these programs either online or in the restaurant, often through a mobile app or a physical loyalty card. These programs work on the principles of reciprocity and appreciation. By offering exclusive rewards such as discounts, free meals, priority bookings or special deals, restaurants show gratitude towards their loyal patrons. This not only makes customers feel valued but also encourages repeat visits.

But it's more than just having return customers; loyalty programs also enhance the overall customer experience. They allow restaurants to gather data about their customers' preferences and habits, which can then be used to tailor services and offerings more effectively. This personalized approach strikes a chord with guests, who appreciate the extra effort taken to cater to their tastes. Moreover, these programs create a sense of community among loyal patrons who enjoy being part of an exclusive club with unique perks. This feeling of belonging often leads to positive word-of-mouth referrals - bringing in new clientele without incurring any additional marketing costs.

Importance Of Loyalty Programs In The Restaurant Industry

The restaurant industry has seen remarkable growth in recent years, becoming more bustling and competitive than ever. As the battle for the customer's attention and loyalty intensifies, restaurants are turning toward loyalty programs as a key differentiator. A carefully crafted loyalty program not only assists in retaining existing customers but also helps attract new ones. They instill a sense of belonging in customers, leading to repeat business and higher customer lifetime value. According to a study, a 5% increase in customer retention can lead to a 25% to 95% increase in profits, underscoring the importance of customer loyalty in today's restaurant industry.

Why Your Restaurant Needs A Loyalty Program

As a restaurant owner, you may be wondering if investing in a loyalty program is worth it. The answer is yes! A well-designed and executed loyalty program can bring numerous benefits to your establishment, such as increased customer retention, improved brand perception, and higher revenue.

Customer Retention

One of the primary reasons why restaurants should have a loyalty program is to retain customers. By offering incentives and rewards for repeat business, you create a strong incentive for customers to keep coming back. This not only boosts their satisfaction with your brand but also increases the likelihood that they will choose your restaurant over others in the future.

Improved Brand Perception

Loyalty programs can also play a significant role in shaping your restaurant's brand perception. When customers feel valued and appreciated through a loyalty program, they are more likely to have a positive view of your brand. This can lead to increased customer satisfaction and word-of-mouth recommendations, which can ultimately contribute to the growth of your business.

Increased Revenue

A well-designed loyalty program can also have a direct impact on your restaurant's revenue. By encouraging customers to return and spend more money, you can see a noticeable increase in sales. Additionally, loyal customers are more likely to try out new menu items or promotions, leading to additional revenue opportunities.

Data Collection

Another benefit of having a loyalty program is the opportunity for data collection. By tracking customer behavior and preferences through their participation in the program, you can gain valuable insights that can inform your marketing strategies and menu offerings. This data can also help you identify your most loyal customers and target them with personalized offers to further increase their loyalty.

Increased Engagement

Loyalty programs can also increase customer engagement with your brand. By offering rewards and incentives, you are giving customers a reason to interact with your restaurant more frequently. This could include activities such as checking in on social media, filling out surveys, or participating in special events. These actions not only strengthen the relationship between your brand and the customer but also provide valuable feedback that can help improve your business.

Competitive Advantage

In today's competitive market, having a loyalty program can give your restaurant an edge over competitors. Customers are more likely to choose a restaurant that offers rewards and benefits for their loyalty than one that does not. This can also attract new customers who are looking for incentives to try out a new restaurant. By offering unique rewards and experiences, you can differentiate your brand from others in the industry.

What Are The Best Restaurant Loyalty Program Incentives?

With the growing trend of online ordering, it is essential for restaurants to integrate their loyalty programs with popular platforms such as Grubhub, Uber Eats, and DoorDash. This not only makes it convenient for customers to earn and redeem rewards but also increases brand visibility and attracts new customers.

Points-Based Rewards

Points-based rewards are a common type of loyalty program where customers earn points for every purchase and can redeem them for rewards or discounts. This type of program encourages repeat visits and increases customer spending, making it beneficial for both parties involved. To ensure the success of a points-based rewards program, restaurants should set attainable point levels and offer attractive rewards that align with their brand.

Item-Based Rewards

Item-based rewards, such as free items or discounts, are effective in driving customer loyalty as they provide immediate gratification. Popular examples of this type of program include Starbucks' rewards program, where customers earn stars for each purchase and can redeem them for free drinks or food items. It is essential for restaurants to offer unique and desirable rewards to stand out from competitors and keep customers engaged.

Subscription Rewards

Subscription-based loyalty programs are on the rise, with restaurants offering exclusive perks or discounts for a monthly fee. This type of program not only increases customer loyalty but also generates recurring revenue for the restaurant. Restaurants that have implemented subscription programs include Five Guys, Farmer Boys, and Jet's Pizza.

Promotional Rewards

Limited-time promotions and offers can create a sense of urgency and encourage customers to make repeat visits. These types of rewards are especially effective during seasonal or holiday periods, as they can help generate buzz and attract new customers. Restaurants should utilize online platforms such as social media and mobile apps to promote these rewards and track customer engagement.

Online Rewards

Online rewards, such as points or credits that can be redeemed for future purchases, provide convenience for both customers and restaurants. Customers can easily access and redeem their rewards through online platforms, and restaurants can track customer engagement and tailor promotions accordingly. By offering online rewards, restaurants can also increase customer retention and encourage repeat business.

Successful Examples Of Restaurant Loyalty Programs

There are numerous case studies of restaurants successfully implementing loyalty programs that have increased customer retention and boosted sales. Some of these success stories include:

Tarka Indian Kitchen

Tarka Indian Kitchen's loyalty program stands out with its extensive benefits and rewards. Through this program, patrons get to celebrate their birthday with a complimentary meal and are automatically enrolled in a tiered membership system. Customers accrue points for every online order and referral—a strategy that not only encourages repeat business but also broadens Tarka's customer base. The program has significantly boosted customer retention and fostered a community of loyal customers who look forward to their next meal at Tarka Indian Kitchen.

Juice Press

Juice Press's loyalty program, which offers exclusive discounts and early access to new products, has contributed to their strong customer loyalty and repeat business. By offering personalized rewards based on customer preferences, Juice Press has created a personalized and engaging experience for its customers. The program also incentivizes customers to try new menu items, leading to increased sales and brand awareness.

Happy Chicks

Happy Chicks' reward program offers free meals and merchandise after a certain number of purchases. This not only rewards loyal customers but also encourages them to try out new menu items, increasing overall sales for the restaurant. The program also offers additional perks, such as VIP events and personalized recommendations based on purchase history.

FSC Franchise Co.

FSC Franchise Co.'s loyalty program allows customers to earn points for every purchase at any of its franchise locations. This encourages customers to try out different locations within the franchise and increases brand awareness. By offering rewards for purchases at any location, FSC Franchise Co. has fostered a sense of loyalty among its customers and increased customer lifetime value.

Erbert & Gerbert's

Erbert & Gerbert's loyalty program offers rewards after a certain number of purchases, such as free sandwiches or discounts. This not only rewards loyal customers but also incentivizes them to keep coming back for more. By offering rewards for specific menu items, Erbert & Gerbert's has successfully increased sales and customer engagement. Customers can easily track and redeem their rewards through Erbert & Gerbert's website.

Jet’s Pizza

Jet’s Pizza's loyalty program, called "Jet’s Rewards," allows customers to earn points for every dollar spent and redeem them for free pizzas or other menu items. The convenience of being able to track rewards and order online through the website or app has made this program a hit among customers. By providing exclusive deals and offers for members, Jet's Pizza has fostered customer loyalty and increased sales.


Arby's loyalty program, called "Arby's Extras," allows members to earn points for every dollar spent and redeem them for free food items or discounts. The program also offers exclusive deals and offers available only to Arby's Extras members, motivating customers to join the loyalty program. By providing rewards for purchases at any location, Arby's has successfully increased customer retention and encouraged repeat business.

Five Guys

Five Guys' loyalty program stands out with its unique brand voice and approach to customer engagement. By communicating with customers in a fun and distinct manner, Five Guys has successfully created a strong sense of brand loyalty among its customers. Through personalized offers, tiered membership levels, and other unique strategies, this program has increased customer retention and boosted sales for the restaurant.

Farmer Boys

Farmer Boys' loyalty program is built on its commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and catering to diverse dietary preferences. The restaurant offers a variety of options for customers with specific diets, such as vegetarian and gluten-free options. By promoting sustainability and supporting local farmers, Farmer Boys has created a strong bond with its customers and fostered customer loyalty.

Interested in learning more?

For restaurants, loyalty programs have become crucial for retaining customers and standing out from competitors. Don't get left behind in the race to attract and retain digital customers. ItsaCheckmate helps restaurants integrate with several loyalty providers through our first-party ordering solutions. Alongside our partners, we help restaurants create unique experiences tailored for your customers. Book a demo to learn more about our solutions!

Stay up to date

Get the latest articles directly in your inbox, stay up to date